Best Medicine (2026) Series: Comfort TV with Enough Friction to Keep the Blood Pressure Up

A brilliant surgeon leaves Boston to become a doctor in the small town where he spent childhood summers. Despite his medical skills, his rude manner alienates locals as he battles hidden phobias and struggles with personal connections.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t4cDzG9iAms

So I finally sat down with Best Medicine - the new Fox dramedy that takes the beloved British crank-doctor formula, gives it a shiny American haircut, and drops it on the East Coast like a lobster pot with feelings. Officially, it’s an American reboot of Doc Martin. Unofficially, it’s what happens when you take the fantasy of escaping the city, add a medical degree, and then realize the locals won’t let you escape anything - not their stories, not their festivals, not their emotional support opinions.

Here’s the setup, spoiler-free and blessedly simple: the lead (Josh Charles) plays Dr. Martin Best, a brilliant surgeon who bails on Boston to become the general practitioner in a small fishing town where he spent childhood summers. He’s medically gifted, socially… let’s call it “philosophically opposed.” His bedside manner lands somewhere between DMV clerk on day 400 of the heat wave and your uncle explaining how to load the dishwasher “the right way.” Meanwhile, the town responds the way small towns always respond to an outsider: with warmth, suspicion, unsolicited life advice, and enough personal oversharing to qualify as a group therapy field trip. Oh - and he’s hiding a phobia that complicates the whole “doctor” thing in a way the show makes very clear up front.

If you’re getting Doc Hollywood vibes, you’re not crazy. This is that same cinematic comfort-food recipe: big-shot medical guy meets small-town reality and discovers he can’t just brute-force his way through human relationships with a stethoscope and a glare. The difference is: Doc Hollywood was a movie with the luxury of wrapping everything in a neat bow before you could even finish your popcorn. Best Medicine is a weekly appointment. You don’t just visit this town - you start paying rent in it.

Now, let’s talk first impressions. The show is a little stiff at the beginning. Not “turn it off immediately” stiff, but “everyone’s still wearing their new shoes and walking carefully so they don’t crease them” stiff. The rhythm takes a minute to settle. Give it a chance to breathe before you judge it like it just keyed your car. Once it relaxes into its own gait, you can feel what it’s aiming for: the right emotional beats at the right times, without drowning you in syrup. It wants to be heartfelt, but it also wants to be funny - and not the “we all clap because someone said something mildly sassy” kind of funny.

And yes, it has all the feels - often in the sneaky way, too. One minute you’re chuckling at small-town chaos, the next minute you’re catching a surprisingly sincere moment and thinking, “Fine. Fine! I have a soul. Happy now?” The show knows exactly when to tug the heartstrings, which is impressive, because it also includes some cheesy characters who make you want to punch them in the throat. Metaphorically. Relax, standards-and-practices. I mean the kind of “punch in the throat” where you’re actually just reaching for the remote like it’s a safety blanket and whispering, “Please stop talking.”

Let’s hit the supporting cast. Abigail Spencer is a strong counterbalance as Louisa Gavin, the local schoolteacher who doesn’t melt instantly under Dr. Best’s charm - mostly because his charm is locked in a basement somewhere under a sign that says DO NOT ENTER WITHOUT PERMIT. Josh Segarra as Sheriff Mark Mylow is the hometown lawman type - smooth, ingratiating, plugged into every relationship in town like he’s running an emotional switchboard. It’s a smart trio setup because it gives you tension without needing car chases or serial killers. Just vibes. And grudges. And the slow grind of people learning each other.

Then there’s Elaine. Elaine, Elaine, Elaine. The assistant character (played by Cree) is written to be chaotic, distracting, and “modern - the kind of person who seems like she was built in a lab using equal parts caffeine, social media, and the phrase “Wait, what?” as a love language. Some viewers will find her “endearing.” I found her irritating. Not irredeemable - just… aggressively present. She’s the human version of a phone notification you can’t dismiss because you’re wearing gloves.

Now, here’s where we get into what will be the spicy paragraph in the comments section. The woke message is introduced right away. Check boxes marked. Ideology on full display. It’s not subtle, and it’s not meant to be. If you’re the kind of viewer who likes your entertainment to entertain first and sermonize later (or never), you’ll notice the signaling early. If you like that sort of thing, you’ll probably feel warmly affirmed. Either way, the show makes its intentions clear: this town isn’t just quirky; it’s also Very Online in the way modern TV towns tend to be - even when they’re supposedly fishing villages where people should be doing, you know, fishing.

And right on cue, our protagonist has to be flawed for there to be a story. Of course he does. Television can’t just let a competent man do his job and go home. That would be called “a documentary.” So Dr. Best is brilliant but prickly, effective but alienating, driven but emotionally constipated. Which, to be fair, is basically the personality profile of half the people I’ve met who can do advanced math in their head. The show leans into the idea that skill doesn’t equal wholeness. You can save lives and still be a mess at Costco. That’s not just a plot device; it’s a whole modern condition.

What I appreciate is that Best Medicine doesn’t pretend this is new. It’s working a familiar groove on purpose. It’s a reboot of a show that already proved the formula works, and it’s not ashamed of that. In fact, one of the best things about it is how shamelessly it commits to the comfort of routine: small-town rituals, recurring faces, problems that feel big in a small place, and a lead character who keeps insisting he wants to be left alone while the town keeps responding, “That’s adorable. No.”

And for all my grumbling - because complaining is the cardio of the soul - this is the kind of show that can become a weekly palate cleanser. It’s not trying to reinvent the medical genre. It’s trying to be warm enough that you come back, and sharp enough that you don’t feel like you’re eating mashed potatoes with no salt. Critics have generally landed in that same neighborhood: solid lead, cozy tone, mixed-to-positive response overall.

The biggest compliment I can pay it is this: I started it expecting a paint-by-numbers reboot. I kept watching because, once it loosens up, it earns its sweetness. Even when it’s annoying. Even when it’s a little preachy. Even when Elaine makes me want to file a noise complaint with the sheriff - who, by the way, is already on it, because this town knows everyone’s business before the ink dries on the thought.

Ranking: 7.0 /10.

#BestMedicine #DocMartin #FoxTV #Hulu #CTV #Crave #TVReview #MedicalDramedy #JoshCharles #SmallTownDrama